Friday, December 30, 2016

Beauty in Complexity

I’ve always been able to see the beauty of creation in the natural world. To me, I am able to see the artistry of God in the things he has surrounded humans with, soaring pines, brilliant sunsets, and loons drifting over misty northern lakes. In fact, many times I see humanity as intrusion into that beauty. Litter reminds me of the sinfulness and destructive tendencies of mankind. Even my own mind is a source of ‘sin pollution’ and anxiety. In that sense, when I hike I am echoing the actions of the Desert Fathers who sought out solitude to escape the excesses and sins of humanity. In this I have often struggled to see the beauty in humanity---struggled to see past the seemingly infinite evil and depravity that we are capable of. To watch the news, or even to experience a painful relationship gives one the impression that we are creatures of infinite entropy. Oh, I know there is great mystery in the fact that we, apart from the rest of creation, were created in God’s image, that we in some unquantifiable way echo some aspects of our Creator. Artistry is often cited as one of these. Yet even knowing this, I struggle to see the beauty in skyscrapers, or medical procedures, or even great art. The purity of mankind is always sullied by moral detritus. It is as if I witness mankind’s fall over and over. Instead, our interminable fallibility gnaws at me until I turn away from the headlines or indeed my own face in the mirror.


Tonight, however I felt a tremor of that beauty. I saw for an instant that human beings are impossibly complex with thoughts, dreams, motivations, and emotions that cannot be conveyed through speech, word, or any other creative endeavor fully (think of the thoughts that pass through your own mind and all of the memories and intentions that spawn them). The beauty of humanity or a beauty of humanity is in understanding the artistry in that complexity. That is a beauty of mankind, to see the intangible complexity glimpsed through conversation, through art, and through action. It is at least equal to the most complex symphony or beautiful wilderness vista. I cannot explain every connotation of being created in the image of our Creator, but I can say that there is artistry in our bones, brushstrokes of infinite precision mapping our minds. We can never know it fully in even the most intimate of relationships but we need to be driven on by that pursuit of beauty to grasp at the exposed strands and appreciate the wonder in them. Beyond all of our transgressions and misdeeds we are woven with strands of gorgeous Divine intent. Lord help me look past the grime, in others, and in myself. Help me never give up the pursuit of beauty in others. Help me do what it takes to see it. Every intricate strand is another praise of your infinite character.

Thursday, December 22, 2016

The Life of Maltbie Babcock

Maltbie Babcock found himself drawn to nature. During the week he was often found strolling what we now call Eighteenmile Creek or enjoying the region’s panoramic view of upstate New York and, in the distance, Lake Ontario. Babcock would set out along the Niagara Escarpment and while away the hours enjoying the surroundings and relishing in the created world.

All told, Maltbie needed the time away as well. He was a vivacious young clergyman who seemed well-suited to any endeavor. Before he entered the ministry in the Presbyterian Church he excelled at schooling, graduating from Syracuse University with highest honors in 1879. He was an avid athlete and competed at high levels in both swimming and baseball. After graduating Syracuse, Babcock enrolled at Auburn Theological Seminary, where, unsurprisingly, he excelled, receiving his degree in 1882.

Maltbie Babcock’s success and personal magnetism continued into the pulpit, first in a church in Lockport, New York and later at Brown Memorial Presbyterian Church in Baltimore, Maryland. He was known to have “an unusually brilliant intellect and stirring oratorical powers that commanded admiration.” He was known to have a luminously creative mind and often produced colorful turns of phrase during his sermons. A contemporary once remarked, “Dr. Babcock loved words. He was an imitable phrase maker. Some of his epigrams will certainly live. They are so pungent and pointed. He loved to turn old phrases and texts around, and show them in fresh and surprising contrasts.” His efforts were not limited to the pulpit though, but overflowed with compassion as well, as he led a fund-raising effort to assist Jewish refugees of anti-Jewish pogroms in the 1880s. He was, in his time, a rising star.

He became so sought after in fact, that in 1900 when he felt the call to ministry to Brick Presbyterian Church in New York City, the residents of Baltimore petitioned to keep him there. An article written for The New York Times even chronicled their efforts. In the end though, Babcock moved back to New York, likely enticed as much by the work of the Kingdom as for the land to which he was born.
In the spring of 1901 he took leave of the city and accompanied some friends on a trip to the Holy Lands. No doubt he relished walking in the footsteps of his Savior and marveled at the vivid landscapes. Perhaps he left footprints on the shore of the Sea of Galilee and peered out upon the waters where Peter, briefly, obeyed the call of the Lord to step out in faith. He saw the world as if anew and likely found deep inspiration both in this beautiful world and the proximity to Biblical events.

We have no record of his thoughts on the trip for, upon leaving Palestine, he and several of his fellow travelers became ill with “Mediterranean Fever” which is now known as brucellosis, a bacterial infection that induces muscle pain, profuse and undulating fevers, and notably, depression. This proved critical for, unbeknownst to most, the gregarious and enthusiastic young man had previously battled with mental illness and in the 1880s had been hospitalized for “nervous prostration” a contemporary euphemism for depression. These struggles, coupled with the effects of this disease proved too much for the bright shining clergyman. On May 18th, 1901, Maltbie Davenport Babcock committed suicide by slitting his wrist and ingesting mercuric chloride in Naples, Italy.

As his body was returned to the land that he so frequently loved to enjoy, those who knew him could only take solace in words of comfort he had once penned to a friend: “During these days of strain and suspense I have wished I could be a little help to you. I can tell you that at least, and pray that you may have, from God and your friends and your own heart, strength enough to get through a day at a time. … You cannot understand, or explain, but you know as well as I, that back of everything is God, and God is light,--- we shall see. And God is love--- we shall be satisfied. It may be a long while, but it will be worth waiting for. Trust Him all you can--- you will be glad you did.”
The man who once walked the fields and trails to draw near to his Creator was laid to rest at Oakwood Cemetery in Syracuse, New York. His body was buried beside the trees under whose shade he had once leisurely rested.

His widow Katherine, likely peered longingly out the windows of their home as if awaiting Maltbie’s return from one of his afternoon strolls. He would return no more. She would later publish some of his writings, poetry and sermons. But these surely brought little solace to the grieving woman. Her heart still yearned for her husband to walk back in the door, stomp the mud from his boots, and embrace her warmly. He often would tell her upon setting out that he was “going out to see the Father’s world.” Now he would see it no more in the flesh. Among the works Katherine published under the title, Thoughts for Every-Day Living, was a poem entitled, “My Father’s World.” The original poem had sixteen stanzas drawn from Psalms 33 and 50 but when close friend Franklin Sheppard arranged it as a hymn in 1915, he selected only three. Sheppard, who signed the work as “S.F.L” so as to not call attention to himself, changed the name, of course, to what we know it as today: “This Is My Father’s World”.

This hymn breathes from the heart of so many  of us still today when the troubles and strains of the world weigh heavy on our hearts and we long for the beauty of the created world to ease our burden. Perhaps now we can see in our minds, the land as Babcock did: the verdant forests of northern New York, stretching off to the horizon with the sun reflecting off the sliver-blue of Lake Ontario glittering in the autumn day.

This Is My Father’s World

This is my Father’s world,
And to my listening ears
All nature sings, and round me rings
The music of the spheres.
This is my Father’s world:
I rest me in the thought
Of rocks and trees, of skies and seas;
His hand the wonders wrought.

This is my Father’s world,
The birds their carols raise,
The morning light, the lily white,
Declare their maker’s praise.
This is my Father’s world,
He shines in all that’s fair;
In the rustling grass I hear him pass;
He speaks to me everywhere.

This is my Father’s world
O let me ne’er forget
That though the wrong seems oft so strong,
God is the ruler yet.
This is my Father’s world.
The battle is not done.
Jesus who died shall be satisfied,

And earth and heav’n be one.

Saturday, December 17, 2016

Top 10 Books of All Time

I often find myself saying things like: ‘that is one of my favorite books of all time’ but I’ve never really sat down to compile such a list. This week I did so and I thought I share it. (These are in no particular order).

-          East of Eden by John Steinbeck
o   My favorite of all Steinbeck’s work. The epic scope of the novel, astounding descriptions of the California landscape, and biblical allusions are just some of the reasons that I love it. Cathy’s character is so utterly evil.

-          Cannery Row by John Steinbeck
o   On a completely different note, Cannery Row (and its sequel Sweet Thursday) is light and heart-felt, telling the episodic stories of Steinbeck’s vagabonds.

-          The Space Trilogy (specifically Perelandra) by C.S. Lewis
o   In my opinion, the Space Trilogy ranks ahead of The Chronicles of Narnia in terms of interesting spiritual allusions. The portrayal of Venus as the counter point to the fall of mankind on Earth is particularly vivid.

-          The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien
o   No one need question my love of and devotion to this story which is broader in scope, plot, and fullness than most others especially in the fantasy genre.

-          The Road by Cormac McCarthy
o   While I am primarily drawn to McCarthy’s novels due to style. The reason why The Road jumps past Blood Meridian is the surprisingly hopeful light in which the author portrays the post-apocalyptic land.

-          The Nick Adams Stories by Ernest Hemingway
o   I’ve always preferred Hemingway’s short fiction to his novels. Nick Adams is Hemingway’s most enduring and self-reflective character. The fact that many of the early stories take place in Michigan is only icing on the cake.

-          To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
o   Amazingly I only read this for the first time last year. This novel presents the reality of racial divides and sin but does so with an unapproached hopeful perspective.

-          Freedom in Simplicity by Richard Foster
o   In thinking of non-fiction works that I return to over and over, Freedom in Simplicity has been underlined more than any other. I find myself returning to it to feel again the simplicity and purity of the gospel when everything else around feels complicated and chaotic.

-          Walden by Henry David Thoreau
o   The way Thoreau manages to draw deep thoughts from simple observations in the natural world is remarkable.

-          The Martian Chronicles by Ray Bradbury

o   As a lover of the short form fiction, Bradbury’s collection of loosely related short stories about the colonization of Mars both intrigues me and gives me hope for my own fiction.

Wednesday, December 14, 2016

The Faithfulness of Abraham's God

Most of the time when we think of Abraham, we do so in the context of his faith. This is quite a natural response since both Paul and the author of Hebrews spend a lot of time emphasizing it. However, as we’ve been reading through the book, what has stood out to me is not Abraham’s faith but rather the faithfulness of Abraham’s God.

We meet Abraham as he is chosen by God, through no inherent justification of his own, to be the father of a great nation that would in turn bless the world. What we see after is a sequence of events demonstrating that this God was so faithful to His promise that He remains true in spite of Abraham repeatedly relying upon human logic to produce an heir (Ishmael) and save his wife (twice). Through it all God remained faithful because God IS faithful. It is an inexorable part of his nature. Not only does he forgive Abraham, but He remains so faithful to His promise that He blesses everyone associated with Abraham: Ishmael (who was not the promised child, yet still became the patriarch of nations), Lot, and even Lot’s daughters (who also produce nations through disreputable and decidedly un-family friendly means). In spite of these questionable circumstances, the Lord blessed them all because He had promised to bless Abraham. The Lord is so faithful that He will not (cannot) go back on his promise.

While it would be easy to apply this verse to show that God is forgiving of our failings (and this is not wrong), I believe there is a deeper truth here, and it involves who God is at the very core of His being. God is not simply faithful, He IS faithfulness. It is an inseparable aspect of His character.

Whether we acknowledge it or not, our actions are the direct result of our beliefs. By beliefs, I don’t mean truths to which we intellectually assent but rather the things we believe at the core of our being. If we believed, at the deepest level, that the Lord was faithful without limitation, how much more would our lives bear the fruit of obedience? How much richer would our faith be? How much less would doubt, insecurity, and complaining tempt us? These are just a few things to think about as we prepare to celebrate the ultimate fulfilment of God’s promise to bless the nations through Abraham’s descendants---Jesus’ incarnation.

Sunday, October 23, 2016

Living in Confession

This isn’t some grand exposition. Rather it is more of a thought I had driving to church today.

Unfortunately, it seems that the longer we have been Christians, the less likely we are to admit our weaknesses. We see in the young and the young in the faith an exuberance that trumps all pretension. Whether they feel they have permission to not have their lives 100% in order or that they are so enamored with the love of Jesus Christ, they seem more willing to lay bare their lives for the sake of fellowship and sanctification. Perhaps as we age and establish more of a history as believers we feel that we should have it all together by now. We always talk about sin in the past tense. We only feel willing to share our struggles with others when we feel that we have properly managed them. How many of our limited years are wasted because we are not honest about our flaws and failings?

John writes in one of his letters: If we say we have no sin we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

There are few of us who would claim that we don’t still struggle with sin. It would take quite a lot of delusion to claim that we were perfectly following Christ. Yet at the same time, we seem to be becoming less willing to own up to that reality. Contrary to our tendencies, the mark of the mature believer should be an increased willingness to confess our lingering sin and selfishness. The condemnation is gone, dead and buried. Our admission may well disqualify us in the standing of men and women who hold perfection as the requirement of faith. Our honesty might cost us. What we gain however, will far outweigh the cost. What we gain is healing, true community, and a renewed and honest relationship with our Creator.

James writes:

Therefore, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed.


I think it’s time we confessed our sins. I think it’s time we admitted our frailties. It’s probably time to be open about our budgets, kids, marriages, our jobs, and our doubts. Our honesty will cost us. But our dishonesty will cost us far more.

Saturday, October 15, 2016

The Tension of Ages

My family and I went out for a fall hike at Stinchfield Woods in Pinckney today. It was a beautiful hike (most of my excursions to Stinchfield have been) though my daughter’s little legs only lasted about two miles. As I drove home through downtown Dexter I passed a cemetery where sporadic, elegant maples towered above the manicured lawns and gravesites. The peak of autumn colors was still about a week or so away so only the slightest hints of their future glory shone in the afternoon sunlight. I marveled at height and breadth of the towering sentinels and wondered how many years it had taken for them to attain such heights. How many decades of drivers passed by or mourners wept in their shade?

The contrast for me was stark: here these stalwart organisms grew, towering up toward the sun outpacing their floral competition while beneath their boughs generations of humans lay buried beneath the good earth. It spoke to me of the transitory nature of man. Though long-lived for mammals, humans pale in comparison to other created things. Everything that encompasses this earthly life exists within the realm of our transitory nature. Our glories dissipate as we breathe our last (if not before) and the things we have accumulated pass into other hands, their meanings slowly lost over the years. We have little hope of any true, lasting impact even among those who we have loved. Eventually, monuments and memories fail and even the most world-shifting impacts become footnotes to history before they too are forgotten to the ages.

As morbid and futile as all this sounds, there is freedom in our transitory state too. All of the trials we struggle with are a breeze that blows but for a moment. All of the strife of this world will pass. The earth-shaking decisions and choices are mere bumps in the road of redemptive history. For those who trust in Christ, even the eventuality of the cessation of life is not final. For us, the comfort that comes in knowing the frailty and ephemerality of man outpaces the momentary troubles of the day, for we will rise.

As we in America struggle with the uncertainty and outright disgust of another presidential election, there remains a joy in knowing that these troubles, as mighty and desperate as they seem, will pass. History will continue. New crises will arise, new joys will be known. As we struggle with the pain and scars that are born from the innate sinfulness of man (there is no real denying that in our current age is there?) there comfort arises when we realize that no moment of time escapes the sight of God and that our history is bound to Christs’. One day, at the closing of our eyes or from the glimmer in the heavens, this age will pass away; our sorrows will be borne and we will experience the freedom and knowledge that comes in the presence of Christ. This, in no way, trivializes our time on this earth, in fact, it is the only way affecting change, calling out sin, or improving the human condition. Yet, it is not in our hands that history is laid.

Moses wrote of the temporal nature of man in Psalm 90:

Lord, you have been our dwelling place in all generations. Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever you had formed the earth and the world, from everlasting to everlasting you are God. You return man to dust and say, “Return, O children of man!” For a thousand years in your sight are but as yesterday when it is past, or as a watch in the night…

The years of our life are seventy, or even by reason of strength eighty; yet their span is but toil and trouble; they are soon gone, and we fly away…

So teach us to number our days that we may get a heart of wisdom. Return, O Lord! How long? Have pity on your servants! Satisfy us in the morning with your steadfast love, that we may rejoice and be glad all of our days. Make us glad for as many days as you have afflicted us, and for as many years as we have seen evil.


Our fleeting nature reminds us that the only change or victory comes from the hands of the Lord. My heart longs to pray with the patriarch as he cries out: “Return, O Lord!”, “Have pity on your servants!”, and “Satisfy us in the morning with your steadfast love.” This is the joy we can take from our frailty. This is the song we can sing knowing that our days are few. Help us to understand that we are dust and to dust shall return. While we tread the rocks and briars of this earth, satisfy us, and hear us as we rejoice in you; in that we shall forever be satisfied by you.

Monday, October 3, 2016

Ode to the Butterscotch Disc

There are many things which I am fully willing to admit that have been lost to our culture’s current obsession with technological progress. Reading, taking walks, honest to goodness conversations. All have suffered in our ever-pressing quest for the new, the better, and the best. Many things have been lost that should not have been lost; things forgotten that should be recalled. Yet at the same time, I am no luddite. Our technological advances have afforded us a multitude of comforts and luxuries. With all of our progress and ingenuity I am baffled at the continued existence of one particular product: the Butterscotch disc.

How is it that in 2016, with the array of absurd and wonderful confections we have access to, that some people are still consuming this hideous and outdated sugar sphere? Surely we have progressed enough that our taste buds demand more.

According to Wikipedia, the butterscotch disc was invented in the 1850’s. You know what else was invented in the 1850’s? The calliope. Also, the hand egg beater and the equatorial sextant. How many of those do we use on a every-day basis? Why then are we still consuming this faux toffee.
Now some of you might find this particular rabbit trail obscure. Perhaps you are correct. Perhaps there is still life in those humble amber discs. Perhaps. Or perhaps there is something more sinister lurking in the nether regions of that glass candy bowl sitting on the coffee table at your grandma’s house.

I may, however, be tainted in my distain for the “treat”. I still can recall the horrifying sensation that occurred when I was yet a child. As a youth I did not go to church regularly. Perhaps I attended on an Easter or a Christmas service, but the only time I found myself at church was with my grandmother who faithfully attended First Baptist Church of Ferndale. It was here that a shadow cast it’s pale gaze over my yet immature life. As I trailed along behind my grandmother on some errand or other, the pastor, a kindly man, offered me a piece of candy from the bowl sitting atop his desk. Innocent enough, huh? I did not steal the candy. I did not otherwise manipulate my way into this reward. It was simply offered, a gift as free as the gospel which would later change my heart. Yet this prize would not promise eternal life but, rather, something far darker.

I reached my tender hand into the bowl and, in the vague innocence of youth, fished out that most horrid of sweets wrapped in the sickly yellow plastic: the butterscotch disc. I don’t remember where I popped the candy into my mouth. It may have been the church or it may have been back at my grandparent’s house. Yet I remember in horrific detail the sensation as the hell-wrought confection lodged itself in my throat cutting off my supply of life-giving oxygen. In what seemed like hours I labored to free the disc which felt perpetually wedged in my esophagus while my grandmother rather calmly offered suggestions. Little did she know that I wrestled a struggle for my very life. Caught in the tendrils of the evil one I sputtered and gagged as the candy slowly dissolved, hoping beyond hope for relief from the pain. Only but for the grace of God did I escape to tell the tale. To this day the mere thought of such a disgusting sweet brings to mind the horrors that this fallen world is capable of. Perhaps, it was this connotation with my then-unregenerate life that led me to understand the connotation and implications of sin and death.

Heed my words friends. Do not be deceived into believing that nostalgia somehow tempers the intentions of this malevolent bonbon. In all our wisdom and progress we have yet to eradicate it from our penny candy jars. Halloween approaches. Spare those that you love the indignity and risk of consuming such a horror. I speak words of truth. Be warned, lest you too fall prey to its evil intent.


By the way, I’m not too keen on Butterscotch pudding either.

Saturday, September 24, 2016

The Vampire

There are things he cannot see. There are things that transpire beyond his recognition. So many doors. So many windows. So many streams all running their courses hither and yon. Ever onward the flow goes, pausing in eddies, sweeping swiftly along the banks. He stands amid it all letting it wash over him like the constant assault of water shapes and polishes smooth rough stones. He lets out a breath taking it all in; taking in the chaos, the tumult.

Before him stands the epic swilling of humanity manifested in a mall food court. Even here, in the dying husk of suburban ideals the expanse is properly occupied. Shoppers sit in pairs or groups sipping Starbucks or nibbling cinnamon buns wrapped in greasy napkins soaked with oil. Grains of sugar grace many a table. All is light. Fluorescent and natural light illuminates the enclosure ensuring that no corner goes darkened either in space or in the human heart. All is seen. All is open. All is illuminated. No deception, no guise, no ruse, only the unabashedly materialistic aims of retailers. There is honesty in that, he thinks.

Yet it is not shopping that draws him out on a golden autumn day. It is not the allure of some unmet need or purchase that beckons.

He watches as the stream of humanity parts before him and he ascends a set of four stairs, freshly waxed and buffed. No stone left unturned. He sees roughly the outline of his own form crudely reflected in the polished tile. As he takes each set he observes the obscure points hanging lights mirrored back at him like passing streetlights on a foggy night. Each step resonates with a satisfying click of his heels upon the floor. Somehow he finds fullness in each step; each hollow reverberation.

He is tall, 6’4”. At fourteen he was already nearly 6”. He wonders if that in some way has shaped his demeanor. Perhaps, had he been a shorter man, 5’6” or 5’8” he would have developed differently. How might height affect one’s view of the world? He considers writing this down. However, he notes that he has had this thought before. Somewhere this surely is scribbled in the margins of some other notebook stored on some dusty shelf; intricately denoted but falling prey to moth and rust, where man can break in and steal. All is fleeting, he muses.

His name is Peter and he is twenty-seven years old. He could hardly be described as fit yet he was also not altogether obese. He was the equivalent of the American average. He’d never lifted a weight in his life but his biceps yet had a well-maintained appearance. A lucky genetic advantage, he mused.
He begins by selecting a table otherwise unoccupied and proceeds to sit, setting his backpack on the floor beside. From where he sits he can look out on the western arm of the mall. He sees the Godiva outlet, an L.L. Bean, and Papyrus, a luxury greeting card retailer. There is moderate traffic up and down the aisle ways; shoppers proceeding to and fro clutching purses and glossy bags, keeping their eyes always on the floor in front of them, on their feet moving like vicious blurry engines.

He wonders how long the institution known as ‘the shopping mall’ will continue to exist. During the growth of the suburbs the mall became the symbol of economic development and cultural utility. The needs of the people, once met by a dozen small stores, became optimized into the shopping mall and the supermarket. Big box stores grew from this desire for efficacy. Now however with the advent of online retailers, the purchasing power has become fractured again with the ease of obtaining an item from a specialty retailer without the need to seek out a brick-and-mortar store to find it. Even more powerful is the ability for consumers to avoid any unnecessary interaction which for many is a desirable advantage. Yet, paradoxically, the artisanal movement seeks to promote those exact things: customer interaction with the producer and locally produced products. In both of these scenarios, the shopping mall is doomed. It loses its advantage of having all the desired items in one place to the internet while for those desiring personal connection and sustainability it is often viewed as a nameless, impersonal husk; a cavernous corporation sucking the life from individuals, taking away the very core of what it means to be human.

Here, too, in the breadbasket of the Great Lakes region, the small towns which once sustained it were dying a slow, protracted death. Mainly due to the corporatization of large scale farming operations, the small farmer was being increasingly pressured to sell out and move to the larger towns. Kalamo, Vermontville, Nashville all once sent their teens in to flood the aisles with teenage angst and expendable income. Now, the clientele consisted of mainly local shoppers.

Dappled autumn sunlight streams in from a cloudy skylight and in it the man feels the comfort of the season. Stores display the muted natural colors of fall. Cut out leaves and window clings adorn the many glass panels. All is decorated for the season. It has always been his favorite, he muses. Even now he can smell the freshly cut fields where combines idle expelling their exhaust into the waiting sky. He sees farmers warming their hands beside fires and swapping stores of better times; better harvests. In all there is a sense of yearning; yearning for better days, better harvests. It seeps from the ground, from the trees, from the sky--- a sense of loss. What it is exactly he cannot quite grasp. They themselves cannot grasp. A void; an aborted future perhaps leaving an aching hole; a nameless expanse they seek to fill with story and recollection. They’ll cast their votes for politicians from bigger cities promising to return to the greatness of an American era that never existed and eat heartily of the promises of the rosy remembrances of their own lost youth. They’ll stretch out their hands to take hold of some illusion; a mirage. The man does not fault them for this exactly. He can feel their loss; their desperation. He feels the ache in his own bones; the ringing emptiness in his own chest. So he looks at the shoppers treading the tile with a sense of understanding, a sense of camaraderie. He sees them as the children of promises lost. He sees even the mall as the decrepit skeleton of a nation’s dreams and assurances. He sees in receipts and bags the shallow reality of the promises of the past. Here, life continues with the countenance of familiarity but is truly only the dry, flaking exterior of desperation, of a changing world longing to be mourned. He feels it. He feels their pain; their unacknowledged anxiety. He wants to envelop it; to consume it within himself. He knows he cannot yet it nourishes him too, feeding his spirit.

Crossing and uncrossing his legs he begins to observe those who occupy the tables around him. Pair of twentysomething women sit with their eyes focused on their Panda Express which they pick at with plastic forks. Neither makes eye contact and they eat in silence. One, a regal looking blonde, wears several gaudy rings that belie her otherwise distinguished appearance. A Forever 21 bag rests at her feet.

Her companion wears a mask of absolute indifference. She consumes her Black Pepper chicken as if it were some type of obligatory nutritional supplement that must at all costs be consumed. She appears to take no pleasure it in.

Why is she even bothering to eat? the man wonders. Is the dining experience merely a utilitarian ritual? What unspoken disagreement leads these two to dine in silence? Surely they came here unbidden. No parent or children surround them to implicate a familial responsibility. Two friends attend a mall yet each maintains a peculiar indifference toward the other. Was there a disagreement? These questions flood the man’s mind. Questions he is unable to answer. Questions he will never know the answer to. Secrets that will lie like bloated corpses in an unmarked grave.

After a moment, a young professional looking man sets down on the ledge that serves to separate the upper level of the mall from the recessed food court. He crossed his legs, right over left and settled himself against the cement puncheon, pulling a freshly purchased book from his bag. Peter hears the crisp cover crack as the young man opens it for the first time. It is Stephen King’s Song of Susanna. He smiles.

“Getting close to the end, eh?” Peter asks leaning to his left to address the man. He plants his right hand on his ankle to stabilize himself.

“Huh?”

The Dark Tower, you’re getting close to the end?”

“Oh,” the man says with an air of recognition. His demeanor changes as if a veil is lifted. “yeah, only two more books to go.”

“Have you read them before or is this your first time?”

“First time, my brother read them years ago and is always raving about them. They’re making a movie of the first once I think, so I figured that if there was a time to read them, it was now. My brother has pretty good taste.” He says this last bit with a bit of vagueness.

“So, I don’t mean to pry,” Peter says lifting himself up and turning his chair around to face the young man, “what order did you read them in? I mean did you read The Wind Through the Keyhole where it’s placed in the series or are you waiting till the end to read it?”

“I read it in order.”

“See, I wish I could go back and do that. I finished the series before Wind Through the Keyhole came out so I had to read it afterwards. I wish I could have gone back completely blind like you did and read it in order. It really changes the way you read and interpret the book.”

“I don’t know. It wasn’t my favorite anyway.”

“What’s your favorite?”

“Right now? I think Wizard and Glass. It felt really satisfying to hear Roland’s backstory. I’m Branch, by the way.”

“Peter,” he says shaking the man’s hand.

The two men now face each other as equals, as if linked by some ineffable force. Their countenances are transformed and there is a kindred spirit between the two. Peter makes a mental note to write this down later. Branch puts down the novel.

“Yeah, I always thought that Wizard had the best self-contained story. Though Wolves was pretty good in that regard too.”

“My brother says Wolves is his favorite.”

“Your brother seems to have really good taste” Peter says with an air of pregnant expectation. He is leading and he knows it. Does Branch notice?

“Sometimes I guess. He tends to get into horror more than I do. I mean I like The Dark Tower series but I’m not really into King’s other stuff. You know, Pet Cemetery, The Shining.”

“Well, we’re all into different stuff I guess. Is he older or younger than you?”

“Huh?”

“Your brother.”

“Oh, younger. Three years younger, but I never really felt like he was younger.”

“Why is that?”

“Well, in high school he pretty much hung out with my friends or the other kids in my class. So he was always around me. He just felt like the same age as me.”

“Oh.”

“It wasn’t bad or anything, we’ve got a good relationship. It’s good. We operate pretty much as equals. Even our parents treat us like there’s no difference in age.” A pause. “What do you do?”

“Me? Oh, well I try different things. Right now I’m working for hardware store in Battle Creek. Overnight stock. I like it. I’ve got a team of 3 or 4 that I manage. You?”

“DNR up in Lansing.”

“Oooh, a conservation officer.”

“Nothing like that really. I’m basically an administrative assistant.”

“Still. Do you like the outdoors?”

“Like the outdoors? Yeah I guess so. I’m not really much of an outdoorsy guy though. I mostly took the job because it was the best job available. It’s not like it’s a passion of mine or anything.”

“What is a passion of yours?”

“Look how deep you got with that. Um. I guess entertainment. I went to MSU for journalism for a while but I dropped out and never picked it back up.”

“What did you want to do with it?”

“When I was younger I had dreams of writing editorials. I always felt kind of confined by reporting in general. You know, just giving the facts. It always felt like there was no creativity in it. But editorials I think I could write.”

“You should try again. You’re obviously still passionate about it. Look at how you said ‘I think I could write’. Present tense.”

“I guess you’re right” he averts his eyes. Perhaps he is ashamed. Ashamed of what? Because he didn’t finish school? Peter wants to know; needs to know, but how to ask? He can’t quite formulate the words to present the question. The silence lingers. He knows the moment is passing. He wants to save it. But how? He has pushed too deep. He knows it now. Too deep. Delving too deep.

“What do you…” Peter begins, but is cut short as the man begins to stand up. Picking up again the novel.

“Hey, I need to get going. I’ve got to meet my girlfriend at 1. Nice talking to you though, Peter.”
The shake hands again. Peter leans forward.

“Yeah. Nice” he says as Branch makes his way up the three steps and back up onto the storefront level of the mall. Peter watches as he exits through the eastern wing of the mall.

Peter is alone. Again. He turns his chair back toward the table and rests with his elbows pressed against the surface until he can feel the grain of the wood, its skeletal canyons molding rough patterns into his flesh. He presses until he feels the slight sensation of pain, and then relents. He closes his eyes and lets the sounds of his surroundings wash over him. He tries to isolate and articulate each one. The whir of a blender over at a smoothie shop. Indistinct conversation. Indeterminable wheels on the tile--- a miniscule squeak. A rolling basket perhaps? The moderately melodic whispers of music emanating behind shop walls. Always. Always. Always, the gentle drone of the air conditioner which has replaced the rush of traffic, and, before that, the whooshing of wind through treetops as the ubiquitous omnipresent refrain of these times.

He lets the sound wash over him; lets it fill him, every pore, like air filling a vacuum. He prays for rebirth. Prays for the strength to persevere. He prays for freedom. He prays. He listens for the non-silence; that which would-be silence. He stares in the darkness that is his sealed eyelids. He traces the patterns and colors that swim across his vision; visions of immaterial electrical impulse.

He opens his eyes, his suddenly exhausted eyes. He tries to iron his thoughts flat like a board. Smooth the edges. Smooth the wrinkles. Maintain the balance. Some type of balance. He feels the void lingering, just upon the barriers of his consciousness, always present, always waiting, waiting for just the right moment, the right chink in the armor. No, he cannot relent. He must persevere. He must run the race set out before him.

Unsure of how long he has remained motionless, Peter looks around. Not much time has passed. Minutes perhaps this time? Some of the same diners still remain, now sipping from smoothies or nursing the barest remains of their lunches. The girls have gone however, their silence broken perhaps by some light comment or familiar memory. And where to? No indication. It makes no difference. Gone. Simply gone.

The lunch crowd had dwindled but there seemed to be more shoppers actually walking the halls. Peter rose and threw his backpack over his shoulder, not truly putting it on but not carrying it. He pushed in his chair with a firm but calculated amount of force in spite of the fact that nearly all of the other fifty or so chairs lay about in varying degrees of discombobulation. This one chair; this chair will be clean, will be perfect.

It is easy, Peter thinks, to get lost in the magnitude and the perspective of life; to get overwhelmed by the vastness and ignore the minute things. That is folly, he concludes, it is only in the individual thing that there is any true perspective. He tries to imagine a sky full of stars such as he had seen as a child. The awe-inspiring and crushing reality of one fraction of the universe, the fragment visible from northern Michigan on a summer night in late July. That tiny sliver of reality threatens to eclipse all of life. Compared to that profundity of existence, of what import can one tiny pin-prick of creation maintain? What prominence can any one life have? With all its machinations and memory and feelings and doubt, what can it compare to the grandness of the grand? He knows the answer. He has memorized it; internalized. It is no rote creed though; he knows it deep down in his bones, in the very core of his person. The One does matter. It is in fact the only thing that gives the grandness its wonder. He must seek the Oneness; the overwhelming uniqueness of it all, never relegating action to merely words spoken or deeds done. One chair it may be. One chair amid fifty. But it is one chair that bespeaks the dignity of all.

He walks as if trespassing a world that is not his own, passing shops from which he seemed as far removed as a foreign country. It seemed impossible to him that so many clothing retailers even existed let alone made a profit. He himself had rarely shopped for new clothes over the last ten years of his adult life. What little he had acquired came from the Salvation Army or as gifts at Christmases or birthdays. Attire had never held much sway over him. In fact, he rarely looked in a mirror long enough to form an opinion on his style. Still it was not as if he had pronounced judgement on those who availed themselves to style and accessories. It was simply removed from his own sphere. There were some grey areas of interpretation after all.

“Hey, take a look at these watches” a voice called in a half-hearted sales pitch.

Peter turned to see a kiosk employee, who himself sported a burnished timepiece, beckoning him toward the glass cases. Peter stopped but made no effort to approach.

“You interested?” the sharp-dressed man inquired.

“Not particularly.”

Peter resumed his pace.

He came to the end of the east wing where the halls opened up into a kind of a gathering area just in front of JC Penny’s. There were a number of benches set in a semi-circle where a diverse group of people had settled. A mother leaned forward looking in at her small child in a stroller. Another watched her two children run about in the guarded expanse.

Peter paused to wonder at the world these children would grow up in; the world they would experience. How different would it be from their parents’? Not only in specific differences in events but even deeper at the level of perception. How would they perceive the world? How would a generation raised with computers as functional technology interpret their existence? Would such technological augmentation change their perceptions of information or pain or beauty? He had always been struck at how much our own understanding of the world rests upon our personal (and biased) observations and experiences. What would these children see? Or perhaps more pointedly, how would they see their world?

On the other half of the crescent-shaped row of benches a woman in a sharply tailored suit sat sipping on a coffee and reading a tablet. Every inch of her spoke of control and professionalism. Every hair and eyelash had been meticulously managed.

Peter approached and sat on the bench next to hers.

Retrieving from his bag a small, black notebook, he began to write furiously, utilizing his knee to stabilize himself. He finds himself fighting off tremors that seem to originate at the very core of his being. Every ounce of resolve he can muster he focuses on remaining calm. He waits, savoring each anticipatory breath, feeling it engorge his waiting lungs with cool, sterile air.

At last, he can abstain no longer.

“What’s going on in the world?” Peter asks, desperately striving to sound causal.

“Nothing much,” the woman replies without missing a beat. “You know, wars and rumors of war. Same ole stuff.” Her don’t leave the tablet hovering about ten inches from her face.
“It’s a crazy world.”

“No crazier than it’s always been. We just have more access to it. Not that that makes it any better.”

“Do you really believe that?” Peter asks. The question is genuine. He has wondered that for a long time. In the darkest hours of the night he wonders it. When the weight of the world seems pressed down upon his shoulders and the pain in his mind is a swirling, stinging sensation he wonders and wonders as the embrace of sleep seems lost; a tantalizing echo. In the darkness he wonders.

The woman hesitatingly puts down the tablet. Her eyes are a rich sea of green seemingly flecked with darker browns. Her age is indeterminate. She seemed to be the type of woman who might have been twenty-five or forty. A cadence of beauty surrounded her masking the effects of age. He is struck.
“I think so. All the media we have it makes us think that the horrible events of the world are far more commonplace than they are. Fifty years ago, a hundred years ago, we knew the events that affected us: the events of our town or our state or maybe one or two national events and that was it. We weren’t troubled with more than that. Horrible things were happening but we didn’t know about them. Now we look back and say ‘aww if we would only get back to the good old days; if we could just make America great again.’ It was just the same back then. Though we were unaware of it.”
“You seem like you’ve spent a lot of time thinking about this.”

“I teach Introduction to Electronic Media, it’s kind of my thing. More than that though, I just really get into it.” She makes a conscious effort to make eye contact with Peter, something that she has conspicuously avoid until this point. “I’m Annette.”

“Peter Wolff.”

“Like, Peter and the?” she asks fighting a grin.

“I guess. Parents didn’t really think that one through.”

“Maybe you just looked like a Peter?”

They both laugh.

“What do you do Peter the Wolf?”

“Um, I’m kind of a writer.”

“Ah, that explains it. Great nom de plume though. No one will ever believe it’s your real name.”

“I guess.”

He is alternately uneasy and assured. The woman has that effect on him. He desperately wants to rest in the comfortability that this woman seems to elicit in him. Though he has conversed with many people on many, many occasions, he has never felt this level of rapport. For a moment it breaks his concentration. For a moment.

“Where are you a professor?” Peter staggers.

“Eastern, though technically I’m a lecturer.”

“What are you doing out here?”

“I’ve got Thursdays off and I’ve got a wedding on Saturday in Grand Rapids, an old college roommate.”

“Oh, well thanks for stopping in on our little town.”

“Well, it really was just for gas but I made some time to linger.”

“I’m glad.”

“What?”

“Nothing.”

She eyes him warily now. Her countenance seems to alter. Slivers of distrust seem to flash in those beguiling eyes.

“I’m only stopping in for a few hours. I’m meeting a friend for dinner.”

“Oh. It’s good you have a wedding to celebrate,” he flounders, “with all that’s going on in the world.”

“Yeah,” she begins tentatively, “the only way to cope with the evil in the world is by maintaining the good; celebrating the good.”

“You really believe that?”

“Yes, I do.”

“I wish I could. I’ve seen too much, I think.”

“That’s rough. Not that I know what you’ve seen. But it’s rough to keep the faith when you’ve been hurt,” Annette says with renewed compassion. Peter winces. “Without some standard of morality, the only basis for action is one’s own desires. We all know, either from ourselves or from observing others, that if every resorts to rampant hedonism, that evil will grow. When everyone seeks the best for themselves only then the world very quickly descends into anarchy.”

“It’s not that easy to deny yourself,” Peter says quietly, averting his eyes.

“Agreed, but without it, we enter into a spiral of destruction. We see how that’s working in the world; in this country. When we seek only to elevate ourselves we by necessity denigrate others.”

He cannot bring himself to raise his eyes. He can only stare helplessly at his own worn shoes as if the weather-beaten Keds held in them some glimmer of absolution. He closes his eyes momentarily and relishes in the relief that the nothingness brings; no fear; no temptation; no pain; no regret. Yet even as he revels in this one moment of pure ecstasy, he is also carefully calculating how long he can keep his eyes closed without causing any social complications. One second, two seconds, three seconds. He removes his glasses and rubs his eyes simply to give himself a few more milliseconds of peace. Four seconds, five.

Fighting the desire within himself he asks “how close are you to your roommate?”

“I’m sorry?” she responds, affronted.

“Your old college roommate, how close are you? Were you? I mean what school did you go to?” the tenor of his voice echoes with self-loathing; pervasive and all-encompassing shame.

“Listen,” she begins.

“No, I’m sorry. I... I just was wondering about the wedding, I mean how well did you know them. Um, like are you staying with friends? You said that already. Sorry. Is the wedding in a church? Where’s the reception?”

“I, um, I have to go.” She rises, clutching the tablet and her purse against her side. “It was, nice, talking to you Peter. I’ve got to go. You know. Have a great day.”

She turns to leave. Peter hears the click of her shoes against the tile floor. He does not watch her go. He knows that she is gone. He knows that she will turn once she reaches a safe distance to look back to see what he is doing. He does not move. He does not want to give her the satisfaction. He is not desperate. No, he is desperate.

He feels the familiar disappointment.

He feels the sting of habitual failure.

In through, the nose he breathes, holding his breath until his lungs reach the point of exhaustion, when his entire body is crying out for relief, it is here in this moment that he knows the meaning of control. He holds in his will the power of life and death. With every cell screaming out in desperation he releases the now useless carbon dioxide through his mouth and pulls another gasping lungful into his yearning body. It is here that he knows the satisfaction of having done something to the fullest. Though trivial and inconsequential he knows what it is to have dominion over something even if it be his own body. He knows what it is to do something to the fullest.

He opens his eyes.


The sting of failure still burns strong; the failure to do the best he was possible capable of doing. Yet he is satiated. He can trace the outline of the glimmer of hope in the air around him. He knows he can go on for another day; that he can try again; knows that he must try again. Tomorrow is another day.

Sunday, September 4, 2016

A Plain Account of the Ohio Marsh Man - Summary Thoughts

Prince Eduardo Tovar was pronounced dead at 2:43pm on September 4th, 2020. The identification of his body ended the mystery of his disappearance but begat new mysteries for his family and friends. As we have remarked, there are an array of theories and suppositions posited. For those who knew him, his family and friends, two years of closure were abandoned and in their place hundreds of new questions. What led Prince to this life? What kind of life was it? Was he a homeless criminal? Was he a lunatic? How did he even manage to survive in the wild on his own? In the winter?

Some of these questions have found answers or the beginnings of answers. For many however, the conclusions have felt hollow and unfulfilling. His mother, Maria, counts herself as one of those who sees a deeper mystery behind her son’s disappearance.

“Why did he leave?” she asked in an interview granted this publication, “why? I believe he had a reason—a good reason. He was still good, even in the end. He tried to save that boy. He was still good. He was not a crazy man.”

Still, the claims of lunacy by the media and public officials has maintained constant in the years following his death. To the public record, Prince Tovar was little more than a vagrant who managed to avoid capture for two years. The case is closed; it would seem, on official speculation.

Still, there are deeper questions that remain. What drew him to the sites of tragedies and catastrophes? The Fermi II meltdown and the semi collision were only two (though the most substantiated) of the numerous reports of his appearances just before or during significant events. Who knows how many more of these reports bear truth even though they cannot be verified. Was Tovar somehow aware of these events? Was he attempting to prevent them? The official statement of the facts of his life and death paint a clear and concise picture, one easily filed away, but it lacks any real depth or answers.

For those who knew him, and for those interested parties who cannot brush away the speculation or paint Tovar with the brush of a lunatic homeless person, mystery may always remain. As long, however, as we are willing to ask the questions, we may still remain able to obtain answers. We can look into the life of Prince Tovar, searching beyond the darkness and the pain, and find the light, the beauty he so dreamed that our society would bring. That is his legacy: a man who sought to bring joy and beauty to a fallen world; who sought to emulate the creative spirit of his Creator.


In that conclusion, we may yet find peace.

Saturday, September 3, 2016

What is Making You Happy vol 2

Though it was my original intent to post more of these posts, I have hitherto only posted one. I wanted emphasize the positive potential of the internet, since it is so often a pretty negative place. Here is my humble attempt to remedy this. So without further ado, here are 3 things that are making me happy. Feel free to add your own in the comments.

Night walks for Pokémon

-          Okay, this a bit of a weird thing. I live in a township and therefore don’t get a lot of Pokestops or Pokémon spawning in the area. I still like playing (I’m trying to scale back, I promise) but what I really love is taking walks at night (usually around 10/10:30 and catching a few Pokémon at a local intersection.  I think, honestly, that I really love just having that completely alone time at the end of a day. Now that the weather has turned a corner (hopefully) and cooled down, it makes the time even better. Though I still live with a good amount of light pollution, I can see a good amount of stars on a clear night. It’s beautiful.

Nerd Nights 2016

-          My wife has wonderfully agreed to be part of Nerd Nights 2016 in which we are watching through the Marvel Cinematic Universe movies on Friday nights. This came from a realization that as much as I love this film franchise, I have really only seen the majority of the movies on the initial theater viewing. I really have no idea if they are any good. So we have decided to settle in on Friday nights to re-watch these movies. So far we’re only through Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk so we’ve got a ways to go. My twelve year old self is very proud.

My Youthstaff team members


-          Okay, so this is going to sound a little gushy. I apologize. I have really loved the time I’ve gotten to spend with my team members on my A29 Youth Ministry team. We’ve been planning this semester’s kick-off event: “The Messy Olympics” and they have come up with some absolutely creative and bonkers ideas. They are way messier than I really feel comfortable with, but hey, I’m too stodgy anyway. More than that, it’s been amazing getting to ‘do life’ with these individuals and seeing the way they love students and love the Lord. As a guy who sometimes feels like it’s hard to connect and make close friends, I thank the Lord that he’s given me not only a great team but also given me good friends. 

Friday, September 2, 2016

A Plain Account of the Ohio Marsh Man Part 8

Following the roadside encounter and the strange visitation prior to the meltdown at Fermi II a police memorandum had been issued instructing officers to be on the lookout for “an adult male, approximately 6’ tall, possibly homeless” wanted for questioning. Sources made available to this publication show that the FBI had less patience for the so-called “Marsh man” instructing that should any individual appear on the premises of any federal institution he was to be apprehended immediately. The efforts of law enforcement were of course made more challenging by the proliferation of reports coming in to officials describing interactions with this now-mythical figure. Some of the more outlandish claimed that his origins were extra-terrestrial. Another described in detail how the figure levitated out from the swampy waters and proceeded to advise a young woman that she should leave her boyfriend. Perhaps self-aware of becoming a crypto-zoological “Dear Abby” column, the haunting individual apparently took to the road and reports became common throughout the Midwest, in select cities on the eastern seaboard, and, of course, Florida.

The truth about Tovar’s whereabouts during this time, like much of his story, is murky. There do seem to be some adequately credible reports out of Put-in-Bay and Pelee Island. The possibility of finding a decent degree of solitude on the shores of these islands seems realistic. The reality is that we may never know.

What we can be assured of is that on the morning of September 4th, Prince Tovar woke up from a night’s sleep in the pre-dawn hours. His camp, if one could call it that, was on an untraversed stretch of shore about 5 minutes east of Magee Marsh and about a ten minute walk from Ohio Route 2. That distance might as well have been 10 miles for the spot which he has made his home was nestled in a small cove shallow enough to discourage boats and the entrance covered enough to shade his presence from any onlooker from either shore or sea.

Over the course of the morning he made his way northward along the coast apparently catching fish along the way. By this time he had grown accustomed to eating them raw so there was no need to light a fire. In the remains of his camp there were leavings of many fires so it would seem that he still continued to make them both for warmth and to cook his catch. At any rate by mid-afternoon he had found a spot at Metzger Marsh hidden on an embankment to wait out the day and the various people who used the marsh’s path to run, hike, or bird watch. Tovar was quite cautious to avoid as many eyes as possible it would seem. He must have been quite good to account for his nearly two and a half years of undisturbed wild living.

It seems the most providential and tragic events pivot on tiny twists of fate. Perhaps that is the only time we are truly able to witness and comprehend the complex web of interactions that shape our existence. Either way, those series of choices; those coin flip moments seem to shine out at us in the musings of hindsight.

A scheduling mistake let to Carmen Anghellini getting the day off from her work at Target. She had put in a request form months before for a doctor’s appointment. The appointment got rescheduled but she never rescinded the time of request. She counted it as a bonus.
Instead of sending her children, Marcus, 6, and Tara, 3, to the babysitter she took them out herself. She wanted them to get outside; to enjoy nature like her parents had helped her to appreciate. On a whim, on that simple turn of fate, she decided upon Metzger Marsh to let the kids see the lake and enjoy the animals in the marsh. Marcus loved exploring and seeing new animals.

A row of people lined the canal, set up in lawn chairs with their fishing lines drifting in the slow current. Gulls rose and fell on the winds searching for scraps or trash. While Carmen was getting Tara situated in her stroller, Marcus was already running ahead to the crushed gravel path and disappearing behind the rows of trees. She called for him to return and he obliged. The next twenty minutes her words served as a leash for the young and very exuberant boy. Every time he got too far away she called him back.

The path was surrounded by trees on the southern side for about a quarter of a mile before the land gave way and the path became a narrow strip of land separating the waters of the lake from the waters of the marsh. It continued for about a mile, completely straight until a sign informed them that it was illegal to continue beyond that point.

The straightness of the path gave Carmen confidence she could afford Marcus a little longer leash that normal because at least she could see him. He was attentive and her cry always brought him back.

At about 2:30pm she stopped to help the nearly asleep Tara get her hat back on. When she looked up, Marcus was merely a spot on the horizon. She called out. He was there. Then he was not.

She started to run pushing her daughter in the stroller. This proved cumbersome but her panic helped her stop and adeptly get the sleepy Tara out of the stroller. She began to run. She wasn’t even sure where she had last seen her son. The terrain of the marsh was minimal and every spot along it seemed the same as the last. Reaching the point she thought he might have last been she began to scream; screaming with the desperation of one who has truly lost something infinitely valuable. Other pedestrians tried to ask her questions but she was in no state to explain what had happened. She only knew that her son was gone. Someone called the police.

The placid waters of the marsh were undisturbed. On the other, the waves of the lake lapped away absently against the large blocks of repurposed concrete that served as a wave break.

Moments passed. No one could remember exactly how long.

Officers Andrew Sanchez and Mark Tyler, who had been nearby, responded. Sanchez preemptively called for an ambulance but the two entered the park by themselves. As they started down the trail at a jog they could see where a crowd had gathered. It took them precious moments to reach Carmen who was obviously the disturbed party. Tyler tried to get a concise summary of events out of Carmen but the woman was too distraught. A jogger tried to translate the screams and sobs.

As all eyes scanned the waters of the lake and the marsh around where Carmen stood, no one looked up the trail about 75 feet, where in fact, the boy had actually fallen. Had they been looking, they would have seen a grimy and disheveled Prince Tovar emerge from the lake cradling the limp body of Marcus in his arms. Blood oozed from a gash on the boy’s head where he had collided with the rocks as he fell toward the lake. Tovar, who it is reported never had any training in first aid or CPR was attempting to resuscitate the boy. He cradled the boy’s head in his palms which he held out before him in a limp act of desperation. His eyes fixed on the motionless child he appeared moved (as some bystanders later recounted) and seemed to be near breaking into tears.

This is when Officer Sanchez saw the man or what seemed to be a man, looming over the unconscious boy. He shouted for the man to leave. Tovar appeared not to hear. Officer Tyler tried to hold back Carmen and the crowd that had gathered from approaching any nearer. Sanchez drew his weapon and advanced. From later reports, Sanchez did note that there was a moment when he realized that this figure fit the descriptions of the “Marsh man” and was aware that he was a person of interest. While he might have known, little registered as he approached the unresponsive man crouched over the boy.

Tovar seemed not to register the officer at all, or any of the other bystanders for that matter. All his attention was on the boy, his hands running over his arms, squeezing his hands, trying anything (in this reporter’s opinion) to breathe life back into young Marcus.
Whether it was the desperation and helplessness that drove Tovar we will never know. Perhaps he came to the realization he knew nothing about helping the boy whose life seemed to be speedily slipping away. What we know is that he stood up, quickly, and stepped toward the advancing officer who was about twenty feet away.

Sanchez reacted with two shots at the approaching man. We cannot perhaps blame him for his prejudice. Tovar wore a pair of shorts that were ripped and torn in a dozen places. His hair was overgrown and littered with muck and weeds. Even Prince’s eyes were hidden behind a mop of hair that shrouded his forehead. His appearance, coupled with his curiously ominous appearances surely would have given any officer cause.

None of this mattered of course. The shots hit Tovar in the shoulder and upper chest. He stumbled backwards over the boy and slumped to the side of the trail about five feet back.
Officer Tyler rushed forward to check on the boy, followed closely by the boy’s mother. Officer Sanchez approached Tovar who had collapsed immediately and had not moved. Tovar was unresponsive to the officer’s questions and drawn gun.

The moments passed.

Ambulances arrived about five minutes later. CPR was performed on the scene by EMTs and Marcus began to breathe on this own after a few minutes. The gash on his head was more of a cause for concern and he was lifted onto the gurney and taken to the waiting ambulance as the confused fishermen looked on.

Tovar never again woke.

He lay where he had fallen. One of the bullets had lodged in his shoulder. The other had perforated a lung and his heart. His eyes, hidden behind the grime and the years of neglect stared out in a look of perplexed concern. They would never again see the world. His hands would never again play the keys that he felt brought beauty and life into the world.

We cannot be too quick to lay blame on Officer Sanchez for his use of lethal force. Though we can, and should, ask good hard questions, we realize the complexity and confusion of the situation; the apparently immediate danger to the life of the boy. Indeed, the very bulletins issued by the police department and FBI would indicate such a response was warranted. Sanchez himself has said that he deeply regrets the decisions especially after investigations into the boy’s injuries show that they were most likely cause by a fall onto the rocks and only after, submersion. Marcus, for his part, confirmed as much of this as he could remember. No charges were filed over Tovar’s death nor are any pending.